120
Finance, Accounting and Business Analysis
Volume 6 Issue 2, 2024
http://faba.bg/
ISSN 2603-5324
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.37075/FABA.2024.2.03
Evaluating the Reality and Prospects of IPSAS Implementation in Algeria
Widad Benzine
Department of Finance and Accounting, University Abdelhamid Mehri Constantine2, Constantine, Algeria
Info Articles
Abstract
History Article:
Submitted 4 August 2024
Revised 1 November 2024
Accepted 9 November 2024
Purpose: This study aims to illuminate the current state of public sector
accounting in Algeria and explore the prospects for transition to
International Public Sector Accounting Standards (IPSAS) by
investigating the potential advantages and challenges as critical factors
affecting implementation.
Design/Methodology/Approach: The study adopts quantitative
approach. Data were collected through questionnaires from a sample of
163 participants working in the financial and accounting departments of
government departments across five provinces in eastern Algeria. PLS-
SEM was employed to analyze the data and test the proposed model.
Findings: The study revealed that international harmonization,
structural and organizational transformation, and skills significantly
impacted IPSAS implementation in Algeria. However, the findings
showed that the effect of the accrual basis poses a challenge due to a skills
gap.
Practical Implications: This study provides important insights for
officials, highlighting the need to strengthen the regulatory and legal
framework for government accounting, develop employee skills through
comprehensive training programs, and adopt a gradual implementation
to ensure a smooth and successful transition to IPSAS.
Originality/Value: This study provides an original and timely
contribution to understanding the factors driving the successful
implementation of IPSAS in Algeria. By analyzing the potential
advantages and challenges, this study provides valuable practical,
context-specific insights for officials and contributes to understanding the
path of international accounting reforms.
Paper Type: Research Paper
Keywords:
IPSAS implementation,
Accrual Basis,
Governmental Accounting
Reforms, Algeria
JEL: M41, G38, H83.
*
Address Correspondence:
E-mail: widad.benzine@univ-constantine2.dz
Widad Benzine / Finance, Accounting and Business Analysis, Volume 6, Issue 2, 2024
121
INTRODUCTION
In recent years, many countries have increasingly adopted International Public Sector Accounting
Standards (IPSAS), viewing this transformation not only as an accounting practice but also as a strategic
policy that significantly affecting government performance. International organizations advocate the
application of these standards because they enhance public sector reporting, improve financial management,
and increase government professionalism (Polzer et al. 2021; Al-Kharabsheh 2021). IPSAS adoption is
entirely voluntary, with some countries fully adopt the standards, while others adapted them to their context
(Amiri and Hamza 2020; Christiaens et al. 2010). Accrual accounting has emerged as a pivotal element in
public sector reforms, primarily led by developed countries, underscoring its role in enhancing transparency
and accountability (Jones and Pendlebury 2010). Developing countries have also increased their interest in
transitioning from cash accounting to the accrual basis of accounting to enhance the credibility of financial
information and improve governance (Tawiah 2023; Alshujairi 2024; Miraj and Wang 2019).
Similarly, Algeria has taken a decisive step towards reforming its public sector accounting framework
through two main pillars: enhancing budget transparency and improving public administration performance
(Cheurfa 2022). The aim is to adopt IPSAS, which are expected to making better decisions, allocating
resources, reducing corruption, and increasing coordination among various stakeholders (Boumediene and
Benramdane 2024). However, this transformation faces challenges due to Algeria's specific economic and
political context, characterized by using laws inspired by French regulations since independence. This places
Algeria in a transitional phase that requires effective management of change.
The implementation of IPSAS is a relatively recent topic in Algeria, and studies have begun to explore
this new path. Bouabbana (2020) revealed that the project to modernize public accounting will achieve many
economic benefits, but the pace of reforms is slow due to the lack of readiness in the Algerian environment.
Acha and Ghouini (2020) noted that the cash accounting method used is not suitable for modern public
finance management practices and concluded that Algeria faces challenges, such as poor training and a legal
and technical gap in the public accounting system, impeding the IPSAS application. Khechaimia (2022) and
Boudjellal (2024) indicated that these reforms are part of a new governance approach in the public sector,
progressing towards adopting IPSAS, where the success or failure of this process is linked to effective change
management measures. Bey (2022) asserts that the significant challenge to the success of this transformation
hinges on Algeria's capacity to integrate into the international environment.
These studies have provided important insights. However, the current state of the public sector
remains interesting and deserves further research. Rather than analyzing new laws or soliciting general
opinions, this study aims to illuminate the current landscape of public sector accounting and explore the
prospects for Algeria’s transition to IPSAS by evaluating critical factors affecting implementation,
categorized as advantages that facilitate and challenges that hinder the process. This research employs a
quantitative approach, utilizing a survey of 163 public sector employees in eastern Algeria and analyzing the
data with PLS-SEM.
The paper contributes to provide a comprehensive understanding of the complexities involved in
transitioning to IPSAS, which enriches international literature and offers valuable insights for policymakers
and managers.
The paper is structured as follows: Section 1 presents the theoretical foundations of IPSASs, examines
the current status of public accounting in Algeria, and provides a literature review and the factors affecting
IPSAS implementation. Section 2 outlines the research methodology and tools used. Section 3 presents the
results and discussion, while the final section presents conclusion, implications, and limitations.
LITERATURE REVIEW AND HYPOTHESES DEVELOPMENT
Theoretical foundation of IPSASs
The issuance of IPSASs traces back to the Public Sector Committee (PSC) of the International
Federation of Accountants (IFAC), which later evolved into the International Public Sector Accounting
Standards Board (IPSASB) (Polzer et al. 2021). IPSASB, as an independent board, aims to enhance global
public financial management by elevating the quality and transparency of public sector financial reporting
(IPSASB 2022).
The standards developed in two phases: from 1996 to 2002, when the IPSASs follow International
Accounting Standards/International Financial Reporting Standards (IASs/IFRS) with minor adjustments
in terminology, definitions, and commentary (Polzer et al. 2021). Since 2003, the IPSASB has prioritized
issues specific to the public sector, such as non-exchange transactions and budget implications on financial
reporting (Chan 2006).
The IPSASB issues accounting standards and recommended practice guidelines that promote
applying the accrual basis. To support the accuracy and transparency of financial statements, the IPSASB
Widad Benzine / Finance, Accounting and Business Analysis, Volume 6, Issue 2, 2024
122
continuously updates these standards. IPSASs are designed to address the unique characteristics of public
sector entities whose mission is to serve the public, primarily fund their activities through public resources,
and do not aim to generate profits (IPSASB 2022). A conceptual framework supports applying IPSAS by
defining the primary elements of financial statements and ensuring consistency in accounting practices. The
framework comprises an integrated set of concepts and principles that clarify the objectives of general-
purpose financial reporting (GPFRs), which are primarily to provide information useful for accountability
and decision-making. It specifies the qualitative characteristics of information that support achieving these
objectives, the criteria for recognition of elements, the measurement bases for assets and liabilities, and the
presentation of information in GPFRs (IPSASB 2023). The IPSASB's approach, through standards,
guidance, and a conceptual framework, emphasizes enhancing the quality and comparability of financial
information to meet user needs and promote transparency and accountability in the public sector (Kicová
2017; IPSASB 2022).
The current situation of the public accounting system in Algeria
Algeria has repeatedly reformed its accounting system. In 1995, it adopted the “State Accounting
Plan” project, which was quickly abandoned due to incompatibility with international practices. In 2005, it
embarked on the “Modernization of Budget Systems Project” which aimed to develop public sector
accounting through effective public expenditure management, cost analysis, and asset accounting to improve
information quality and budgetary transparency (Kissi 2012; Khechaimia 2022). However, the
implementation of the project faced problems in practice because the legal framework was not changed in
parallel.
Issuance of Organic Law 18-15
Organic Law 18-15 was issued on September 2, 2018, replacing Law 84-17, the first budget law. The
previous law used a means-based management approach, overlooking performance results. The budget
lacked homogeneity, and its preparation method was not appropriate for strategic projects requiring multi-
year planning (Daddi-ddoun and Oudai 2013; Benkouider 2023). Conversely, the new law incorporates
results-based management to direct public spending, bestows greater flexibility upon managers in
reallocating funds, and restructures the budget to encompass a multi-year perspective (Fahas et al. 2022).
Issuance of Law 23-07 of the rules of public accounting and financial management
It was important to change the previous Law 90-10 because it used statistical records to record
transactions and prepare government financial statements on a cash basis, and it collected information at
the central level with the aim of monitoring flows and implementing the budget, and it did not evaluate
assets (Cheurfa 2022). To overcome these limits, Law 23-07, issued on June 21, 2023, introduced significant
reforms, including the adoption of three accounting types- budgetary, general, and cost accounting- and
shifted towards a management style focused on goals and achieved results. The law mandated the
preparation of financial statements recommended by IPSAS. Furthermore, Law 23-07 enhanced control
mechanisms and emphasized the integration of information and communication technology in public
accounting practices (Loi n° 23-07 2023).
Advantages of implementing IPSAS
The numerous advantages of IPSAS have encouraged widespread recognition and implementation
by countries. The literature review suggests that transparency and accountability, accrual basis, and
international harmonization are the main perceived advantages of these standards, which are important
drivers for their implementation because they add value to public sector financial and reporting.
Transparency and accountability
Transparency and accountability are features that have always been associated with IPSAS.
Transparency involves easily accessible information about government policies, budgeting, and accounting,
enabling a clear understanding of government performance (Krah and Mertens 2023). Accountability, as
described by Rodríguez, encompasses the responsibility of managers to report on resource utilization and
the capacity of citizens to hold them accountable. Williams and Hussein (2019) emphasizes the inherent
relationship between these concepts, as transparency, through its commitment to responsibility, fosters
citizen participation and enhances accountability. Research supports the idea that implementing IPSAS
enhances transparency and accountability. Ogbuagu and Onuora (2019) and Tawiah (2023) explained that
adopting these standards in developing countries will improve the quality of financial reporting and increase
transparency and accountability between government and citizens. Bolívar et al. (2015) highlighted how
IPSAS accounting measurements enhance transparency and accountability by improving information
quality, understandability, and timeliness. Accordingly, the study hypothesizes that greater awareness of the
Widad Benzine / Finance, Accounting and Business Analysis, Volume 6, Issue 2, 2024
123
importance of these features is a powerful driver of IPSAS implementation in Algeria.
H1: Transparency and accountability have a significant impact on the implementation of IPSAS.
Accrual Basis
IPSAS encompasses both accrual basis standards and a cash-based standard. The cash-based
standard, however, is not intended as a target, but is applied as a transitional step towards applying the
accrual basis (IPSASB 2017). Cash-based accounting has shown its limitation, because it only recognizes
transactions when cash is exchanged, which hindering the decision-making, and leading to inaccurate
financial positions; such as because it records properties and inventories as expenses within a single financial
year and does not account for provisions unless emergency liabilities arise (Ashoka and Aswathy 2020).
Conversely, accrual accounting emerges as the best approach, because of its ability to describe the reality of
government activities and determine their costs (Shehadeh 2022), as it recognizes revenues and expenses as
they occur, regardless of the receipt or payment of money. By recognizing assets and liabilities, accrual
accounting facilitates better management and control of government resources, and improves the reliability
and comparability of financial reports (Narsaiah 2019; Saleh et al. 2021). This approach aids in waste
reduction and combatting fraud and corruption, ultimately contributing to social and economic development
(Correa Silva et al. 2022; Alshujairi 2024; PWC 2012). Consequently, this study hypothesizes that the
benefits achieved by applying the accrual basis will be a strong motivation for implementing IPSAS.
H2: Accrual basis has a significant impact on the implementation of IPSAS.
International harmonization
IPSAS plays a crucial role in achieving harmonization in government accounting practices,
enhancing the state’s interaction with individuals, groups, and countries as partners within a global
economic network (Amiri and Hamza 2020). Harmonization under IPSAS encompasses the convergence
of accounting principles, rules, and methods, as well as the content of financial statements (Kicová 2017),
which helps to reduce differences, eliminate additional reporting obligations, and ultimately foster an
environment conducive to attracting foreign investment (Narsaiah 2019; ACCA 2017).
Furthermore, the adoption of IPSAS aligns with the recommendations of international organizations
and countries that grant financial aid and loans by adopting best practices in financial reporting and
promoting accountability and transparency (Amiri and Hamza 2020). Abu Haija et al. (2021) confirmed that
countries adopt IPSAS to enhance their economies, gain global recognition, and attract capital investments.
Salia and Atuilik (2018) emphasized the positive impact of IPSAS on financial reporting quality, which in
turn increases opportunities for foreign aid and foreign direct investment, supporting national development
goals. Implementing IPSAS will establish a common global language and confer international legitimacy
(Bouabbana 2020; Correa Silva et al. 2022).
The study assumes that implementing IPSAS will support the harmonization of government
accounting in Algeria with international practices, leading to more qualitative and comparable financial
statements.
H3: International harmonization has a significant impact on the implementation of IPSAS.
Challenges of implementing IPSAS
IPSAS implementation poses several challenges as it demands comprehensive adjustments,
encompassing legal and structural changes, technical capabilities, investment in infrastructure,
implementation strategies, and associated costs (Ahmad and Nasseredine 2019).
Cost
The promised benefits of IPSAS do not justify the high costs associated with their implementing
(Ahmad and Nasseredine 2019). International organizations recognize the significant financial burdens that
accompany adopting IPSAS, which includes developing new information systems and extensive training
programs on accrual accounting practices, as well as the costs of getting help from external consultants, and
translation expenses (PWC 2012; ACCA 2017; IPSASB 2014). Schmidthuber et al. (2020) found that high
costs as one of the major barriers to implementing IPSAS. PWC (2014) emphasized that governments with
lower maturity in accounting and IT systems, such as those using cash-based accounting, will need to invest
in modernizing their system, facing higher costs relative to GDP compared to governments with more
mature systems. Similarly, Salia and Atuilik (2018) noted that the cost of transitioning to the standards in
Liberia poses a threat to the realization of their potential benefits of their implementationIn Ghana,
Agyemang (2017) found that research costs, training, acquisition of software and hardware, and IPSAS
maintenance significantly affect the adoption of these standards. Whitefield and Savvas (2016) reported that
high costs negatively affected the adoption of standards in Kenya. Redmayne et al. (2019) focused on audit
costs and found that they have increased after the IPSAS were adopted in New Zealand.
Widad Benzine / Finance, Accounting and Business Analysis, Volume 6, Issue 2, 2024
124
This study assumes that implementing IPSAS necessitates substantial investments in human
resources development, infrastructure preparation, and organizational resources. These costs are considered
a major challenge that affects implementing the standards in Algeria.
H4: Cost has a significant impact on the implementation of IPSAS.
Skills
Accrual accounting requires high skills because it is more complex compared to cash accounting (Haji
Din and El Haron 2023; Shehadeh 2022), so the successful implementation of IPSAS is linked to the
presence of qualified individuals with the necessary skills and knowledge. Skills encompass a range of
factors, including knowledge, qualifications, and training, which together contribute to determining the
competence and capabilities of individuals. According to Tanjeh (2016), the greater awareness and
knowledge lead to a more profound understanding of IPSAS, facilitating its adoption. As for training, it
ensures a better scenario for adopting standards because it meets the needs of employees, as it helps identify
the new system, share information, and accommodate changes (Shehadeh 2022). Several studies highlight
the importance of skills in IPSAS implementation. For example, Wang and Miraj (2018) found that South
Asian countries suffer from a significant shortage of skills and capabilities, which has caused slow
implementation of standards. Al-otoom and Alrabba (2022) concluded that employees' lack of self-efficacy
led to resistance in Jordan.
This study assumes that implementing IPSAS is complex and requires more skills than those applied
in current accounting, which will be a major challenge to implementation.
H5: Skills have a significant impact on the implementation of IPSAS.
Structural and organizational transformation
Implementing IPSAS requires changing local regulations and laws to provide the appropriate legal
and regulatory support in line with international requirements. The interpretation of public sector reform by
governments can range from minimal legislative adjustments to substantial transformations of accounting
practices. Roje et al. (2010) noted that countries with developed national accounting systems have made
significant progress in implementing accrual accounting, which has supported their compliance with
standards and harmonization of their accounting practices, while those using cash-based or modified cash-
based systems experience slower transitions. PWC (2014) further suggests that national legislation plays a
crucial role in driving accounting maturity, which countries with mature accounting systems require fewer
structural changes to implement IPSAS, whereas those with lower maturity face substantial legislative and
organizational obstacles, requiring significant reforms to meet IPSAS standards practices. This process is
complex and time-consuming, often spanning several years
(ACCA 2017). Studies such as those by
Aboukhadeer et al. (2023) on Libya and Salia and Atuilik (2018) on Liberia underscore that conflicts
between national legal frameworks and IPSAS requirements present significant obstacles to successful
adoption.
Brusca et al. (2016) and Zibaghafa and Okpolosa (2024) argue that updating accounting systems and
infrastructure is essential because traditional government sector accounting technologies and structures are
no longer suitable. This development will facilitate the implementation of standards and improve accounting
practices and the quality of financial statements (Haji Din and El Haron 2023; Maruf 2024). Abu Haija et
al. (2021) and Whitefield and Savvas (2016) support the idea that investment in technology is a potent
motivator to implement IPSAS.
This study recognizes the critical role of legal reform and infrastructure development in the transition
to IPSAS in Algeria, highlighting them as significant challenges to successful implementation.
H6: Structural and organizational transformation has a significant impact on the implementation of
IPSAS.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Instrument construction
The questionnaire is the most appropriate tool to study this topic. It enables the collection of data in
a coherent and internally consistent manner (Roopa and Rani 2012). Closed-ended questions were used
because they have greater uniformity in answers, reduce errors in understanding questions and variation in
answers, and allow comparison between respondents (Auriacombe 2010; Meadows 2003). The
questionnaire, consists of seven variables, was formulated based on relevant studies, with some modified to
suit the current situation in Algeria, and then it was presented to arbitration for revision (Appendix1). A 5-
point Likert scale was used as a tool to measure and understand the attitudes of respondents (Tanujaya et
al. 2022).
Widad Benzine / Finance, Accounting and Business Analysis, Volume 6, Issue 2, 2024
125
Data collection and sample description
The research targeted employees of financial and accounting departments in government
administrations in eastern Algeria, specifically in the provinces of Annaba, Skikda, El-Tarf, Guelma, and
Tebessa, according to the effort and time of the researcher. These individuals were intentionally selected
because they are concerned with public accounting implementation and have characteristics and knowledge
that align with the research objectives. 163 questionnaires were collected as the employees were very
discreet. The sample included 13 accountants, 31 financial managers, 60 administrators, and 59 other
positions such as administrative assistant or engineer. 33.1% of them have a bachelor’s degree, 42.3% have
a master’s degree, and 24.5% have other non-university degrees or mostly university degrees in other
specializations such as statistics and computer science. 71% of respondents have more than 16 years of
professional experience, while 77% of them have 11 to 15 years of experience, and the rest have less than 5
years of experience.
RESULTS
Partial least structural equation modeling (PLS-SEM) was used; which is considered a predictive
analysis tool that helps forecast causal relationships for designed structural models (Sarstedt et al. 2020;
Purwanto and Sudargini 2021). The data were analyzed in two stages according to several procedures
defined by Hair et al. (2021). The first stage was to examine the quality of the reflective measurement model,
and in the second stage, the structural model was evaluated.
Assessment of Measurement Model
Indicator Reliability
It is important that the measurement model is satisfactory so that the structural model is properly
evaluated (Wong 2019). Examination of indicator loadings revealed that some of them were below the
recommended threshold of 0.708, so the items were removed. According to Hair et al. (2017), the basic rule
is that the latent variable contains at least 4 indicators with a factor loading greater than 0.7, as this allows
explaining a significant part of the variance of the indicators. Removing the mentioned items achieved this
rule in the final model as shown in following figure:
Source: Data processed (2024)
Figure 1. Measurement Model
Internal consistency reliability
Internal consistency reliability is an important property that shows the consistency of responses that
measure the same construct (Ursachi et al. 2015; Collier 2020). Cronbach's alpha values, as shown in Table
1, exceeded the recommended value of 0.7, indicating an ideal level of reliability (Souza et al.2017).
Researchers also advocate reporting composite reliability because it is more accurate and provides higher
Widad Benzine / Finance, Accounting and Business Analysis, Volume 6, Issue 2, 2024
126
reliability estimates (Garson 2016; Hair et al. 2020). The results in Table 1 show that both the composite
reliability values “rho
c
” and the exact reliability coefficient “rho
A
” were greater than 0.70, which enhances
the strength of the reliability of the measures used.
Convergent Validity
Convergent validity, which reflects the extent to which indicators measure the same trait are related
(Byrne 2016), was assessed through the average variance extracted (AVE). As shown in Table 1, all AVE
values exceeded 0.5, indicating that constructs explain over half of the variance of their indicators (Hair et
al. 2017). This finding is considered strong evidence for the convergent validity of the measurement model.
Table 1. Reliability estimates
Cronbach's alpha
rho
A
rho
C
AVE
0.794
0.838
0.861
0.609
0.859
0.867
0.899
0.640
0.852
0.859
0.900
0.693
0.867
0.873
0.900
0.601
0.819
0.821
0.880
0.647
0.823
0.837
0.882
0.653
0.833
0.835
0.889
0.666
Source: Data processed (2024)
Discriminant validity
Discriminant validity refers to the extent to which items relate to each other in a way that distinguishes
each construct from other constructs (Zaiţ and Bertea 2011). The Fornell-Larcker criterion was used,
comparing the square root of the AVE of each construct with the squared correlation between the constructs.
The results in Table 2 show that the square root values of AVE for each construct were the highest, providing
evidence that the constructs are distinct and supporting discriminant validity.
Table 2. Fornell-Larcker criterion
Variables
ACC
HRM
COS
IMP
SKL
STR
TRN
ACC
0.780
HRM
0.171
0.800
COS
0.371
0.266
0.832
IMP
0.201
0.365
0.360
0.775
SKL
0.661
0.269
0.477
0.474
0.804
STR
0.390
0.348
0.336
0.392
0.466
0.808
TRN
0.203
0.451
0.466
0.360
0.363
0.355
0.816
Source: Data processed (2024)
Another measure recommended as a better alternative is the heterotrait-monotrait ratio (HTMT), which
examines the correlation between indicators across constructs compared to the correlations within each
construct (Collier 2020). The results in Table 3 show that all HTMT values did not exceed the threshold of
0.85 (Henseler et al. 2015), further confirming the discriminant validity of the measurement model.
Table 3. Heterotrait-monotrait Ratio
Variables
ACC
HRM
COS
IMP
SKL
STR
HRM
0.202
COS
0.446
0.311
IMP
0.220
0.415
0.408
SKL
0.821
0.308
0.572
0.546
STR
0.490
0.420
0.410
0.454
0.575
TRN
0.256
0.530
0.563
0.415
0.448
0.442
Source: Data processed (2024)
Good results obtained regarding internal consistency reliability, convergent validity, and discriminant
validity are considered indicator of the quality of the measurement model and construct validity, allowing
the transition to structural model evaluation.
Widad Benzine / Finance, Accounting and Business Analysis, Volume 6, Issue 2, 2024
127
Evaluation of the structural model
The structural model was evaluated to estimate the relationships established through a set of steps.
First, it was important to examine linear relationships between constructs to identify potential multi-
collinearity problems; which result from strong correlations between independent variables, which
subsequently affects the reliability of test results (Garson 2016). The variance inflation factor (VIF) was used
to evaluate these relationships. All VIF results, as shown in Table 4, were below the required threshold of 3
(Hair et al. 2021), suggesting that multi-collinearity is not a critical issue.
The second step was to evaluate the significance and importance of the path coefficients.
Bootstrapping analysis was performed with 10,000 subsamples to estimate the weights of the indicators.
Table 4 shows the path coefficients and their corresponding t-values at the 5% significance level.
The results confirm that international harmonization, skills, and structural and organizational
transformation have a significant positive impact on the implementation of IPSAS, while the accrual basis
has a significant negative impact on the implementation of the standards. These findings support the
acceptance of hypotheses H1, H2, H4, and H5, respectively. However, cost, accountability and transparency
were not statistically significant, leading to rejection hypotheses H3 and H6.
Table 4. Hypotheses results
Hypothesis: Path
VIF
Path coefficient
t-values
P values
Decision
H1:
ACC -> IMP
1.835
-0.227
2.880
0.004
Supported
H2:
HRM -> IMP
1.325
0.175
2.313
0.021
Supported
H3:
COS -> IMP
1.508
0.111
1.318
0.187
Not Supported
H4:
SKL -> IMP
2.177
0.426
4.335
0.000
Supported
H5:
STR -> IMP
1.430
0.161
2.172
0.030
Supported
H6:
TRN -> IMP
1.556
0.064
0.710
0.478
Not Supported
Source: Data processed (2024)
The next step was to evaluate the explanatory power and predictive power of the model using several
measures. First, the coefficient of determination R
2
was calculated to evaluate the effects of the independent
variables on the dependent variable (Al-Marsomi and Al-Zwainy 2023). According to Hair et al. (2021), the
R
2
values of 0.75, 0.5, and 0.25 are respectively great, moderate, and weak. Alternatively, Chin (1998)
suggests R
2
values of 0.67, 0.33, and 0.19 are strong, moderate, and weak, respectively. The obtained R
2
value of 0.346, shown in Table 5, indicates that the explanatory power of the model is moderate.
To further evaluate the predictive ability of the model, the effect size f
2
was also calculated. According
to the established standards, values of 0.02, 0.15, and 0.35 indicate a small, medium, and large effect size,
respectively (Hair et al. 2020). The results in Table 5 show that the accrual basis, international compatibility,
and structural and organizational transformation have a small effect size, while skills demonstrate an effect
size approaching the average.
The third measure was Q² assessing the predictive relevance of the model (Janadari et al. 2016). The
procedure for assessing out-of-sample prediction (PLSpredict) was conducted with ten repetitions and k= 10
folds. According to Hair et al. (2020), Q² values of 0.25 and 0.50 are moderate and large, respectively, so the
obtained Q² value of 0.291, presented in Table 5, suggests moderate predictive importance.
Table 5. Explanatory power evaluation
Path
R square
f square
Q square
ACC -> IMP
0.346
0.043
0.291
HRM -> IMP
0.035
COS -> IMP
0.012
SKL -> IMP
0.127
STR -> IMP
0.028
TRN -> IMP
0.004
Source: Data processed (2024)
The mean absolute error (MAE) and the root mean squared error (RMSE) obtained with the same
procedure also represent important prediction statistics. The lower values for these statistics compared to the
naïve LM criterion indicate a good indicator (Hair et al. 2021). The results, presented in Table 6, demonstrate
that all indicators meet the criterion, suggesting that the model has high predictive ability.
Widad Benzine / Finance, Accounting and Business Analysis, Volume 6, Issue 2, 2024
128
Table 6. Predictive power evaluation
Items
PLS-SEM_RMSE
PLS-SEM_MAE
LM_RMSE
LM_MAE
IMP1
0.600
0.484
0.662
0.523
IMP2
0.599
0.484
0.621
0.488
IMP3
0.665
0.537
0.712
0.555
IMP4
0.594
0.479
0.638
0.511
IMP5
0.573
0.474
0.622
0.510
IMP6
0.537
0.424
0.565
0.430
Source: Data processed (2024)
DISCUSSION
This study highlights advantages and challenges as latent variables affecting IPSAS implementation
in the Algerian context. Model analysis using PLS-SEM revealed that although transparency and
accountability are recognized benefits associated with IPSAS, it had no impact on implementation (β=0.064,
P=0.478), which is contrary to similar studies conducted in Iraq (AL-Quraishi and Boumediene 2023) and
Jordan (Al-Kharabsheh 2021). A likely explanation for this result is that transparency and accountability do
not constitute a strong motivation for implementing standards, as they may be overshadowed by other
political, economic, and cultural factors that are more important in the Algerian context. For example,
according to Brusca et al. (2013), political support backed by laws was a major factor in accelerating the
adoption of IPSAS-aligned standards in Spain. According to Ahmad and Nasseredine (2019), Alshujairi
(2024), and Babatunde (2017), the financial burden constitutes the greatest obstacle to implementing IPSAS
in developing countries. Correa Silva et al. (2022) found that national culture and dominant ideology play a
crucial role in implementing standards. Therefore, this result reflects the local context in which the study
was conducted and testing of the hypotheses has already proven that there are other more influential factors
that make it superior to accountability and transparency.
The study found a negative impact of the accrual basis on IPSAS implementation (β=-0.227,
P=0.004). This result was unexpected because the accrual basis is an important feature associated with the
standards. The appropriate explanation for this relationship is that the study was conducted early in the
transition to IPSAS. During this period, the budget was modified into a single document as the first step
towards change. However, Algeria's current public accounting system is still subject to the code-law system,
applies the cash basis, and works according to the commitments-based budget as a system of parliamentary
appropriations (Brusca et al. 2013). Therefore, negative perceptions are likely due to the lack of experience
and knowledge necessary to apply accrual accounting. Gkouma and Filos (2022) highlight that
implementing the transition to IPSAS for the first time in Greece required a deep understanding of the
principles and practices of the standards. Saleh et al. (2021) also confirms that the lack of specialized
employees in finance and accounting impedes the implementation of standards because the change in
accounting techniques from simple cash accounting to accrual basis requires specific skills. This aligns with
some observations about the study sample, as some participants possessed specializations in fields such as
automation and statistics, or had lower educational levels than required, as their field experiences alone will
negatively affect the understanding of accrual accounting.
International harmonization has a significant impact on IPSAS implementation (β= 0.175, P=0.021).
This result aligns with previous research that has confirmed the harmonization of accounting practices and
financial statements as one of the main reasons for IPSAS implementation, ultimately aiming to enhance
comparability across different levels of government (Brusca et al. 2013; Christiaens et al. 2015; Schmidthuber
et al. 2020; Ben Amor and Damak Ayadi 2019). In Algeria, implementing IPSAS represents the adoption
of a unified global language for government accounting, fostering understanding and trust with international
partners and organizations. This harmonization will facilitate integration into the global economy by
streamlining cross-border transactions and attracting investors. Moreover, IPSAS implementation will
improve financial management practices and ensure adherence to international disclosure requirements.
Boumediene and Benramdane (2024) assert that implementing IPSAS in Algeria will legitimize the
government's financial operations, aligning them with international practices. Since international
harmonization implicitly improves accountability and transparency, this supports the results of the first
hypothesis that its impact has overshadowed the impact of accountability and transparency.
Cost does not significantly impact on the implementation of IPSAS (β= 0.111, P=0.187). This result
diverges from several studies (Alshujairi 2024; Babatunde 2017; Ahmad and Nasseredine 2019), which
found that costs are one of the main obstacles facing the adoption of standards. One possible reason for this
result is that the IPSAS implementation process follows a gradual approach (Mazhambe 2021), allowing for
phased transformation that takes into account capabilities and resources, thereby managing costs in phases.
Widad Benzine / Finance, Accounting and Business Analysis, Volume 6, Issue 2, 2024
129
Although implementing IPSAS is associated with financial burdens, these are largely one-off costs spread
across the project’s duration and ultimately outweighed by long-term benefits that are expected to be
significant PWC (2014). Diniz et al. (2015) found that understanding that the benefits of IPSAS are higher
than the costs contributes to the implementation of the standards. Additionally, this result may suggest that
government support, driven by Algeria's political will, has a crucial role in implementing IPSAS, as the state
provides the necessary funding to cover the transfer burden, which reduces employees' perceptions of costs.
This finding is clearly related to the local context, where costs are still unclear in the initial phase of IPSAS
implementation.
The study indicates that skills have the most significant impact on the implementation of IPSAS (β=
0.426, P= 0.000). This skills gap is a common issue in many countries. For instance, (Alshujairi 2024) found
that Iraq suffers from a lack of qualified accountants and trained human resources to implement IPSAS.
Similarly, Ahmad and Nasseredine (2019) revealed that employees in Lebanon face practical difficulties in
implementing the standards. The successful implementation of IPSAS relies heavily on the requisite skills
and knowledge. In Algeria, the great challenge will be transforming the mentality of employees who have
been accustomed throughout their careers to implementing balance sheet tasks. These employees will need
to develop their financial and accounting knowledge to understand standards, work on an accrual basis, and
evaluate assets. Takarli and Ghrissi (2024) assert that the changes associated with the application of the
accrual basis in Algeria will challenge established employee. This result also suggests the difficulty of
integrating employees with lower levels of education or irrelevant diplomas to understand the rules of accrual
accounting, as this challenge was highlighted in the result of the second hypothesis.
Structural and organizational transformation has a significant impact on IPSAS implementation
(β=0.161, P=0.030), which highlights the critical role of laws and infrastructure in facilitating the
implementation of these standards in Algeria. Gkouma and Filos (2022) points out that the implementation
of IPSAS requires legislative reforms to integrate it into state law. Similarly, Boumediene and Benramdane
(2024) emphasized that the application of IPSAS in Algeria requires the preparation of political and legal
factors. The recent legislative reforms in Algeria are a first step in encouraging the adoption of IPSAS
(Boudjellal 2024). The regulatory framework for implementing the standards remains incomplete, requiring
further guidelines and practical rules. Moreover, the results of this study support Zibaghafa and Okpolosa
(2024) and Ademola et al. (2020) studies that confirmed that infrastructure and technology are important
factors in meeting the requirements of IPSAS.
CONCLUSION
This study examined the reality and prospects of implementing IPSAS in Algeria, highlighting the
significant factors affecting it. The findings underscore the significant roles of skill development, legislative
and infrastructural improvements, and enhanced international harmonization in driving successful IPSAS
implementation. Interestingly, the study revealed other unexpected findings that were traditionally
considered crucial for implementation. The lack of a significant impact from cost considerations,
transparency and accountability, coupled with the negative impact of the accrual basis, highlights the
importance of considering the environmental differences and the stage of implementation.
To the best of our knowledge, this paper is the first to identify and model the relationships between
key factors affecting IPSAS implementation in Algeria. This paper contributes to the theoretical discourse
on public sector reforms and the evolution of government accounting, as the findings provide an informed
understanding of the potential factors impacting IPSAS implementation and illustrate their role in achieving
international accounting convergence.
The findings present important practical implications. The study underscores the importance of
structural and organizational reforms to facilitate IPSAS implementation. Specifically, strengthening the
regulatory framework of public accounting is crucial. Achieving this will involve introducing laws and
regulations that support Organic Law 18-15 and Law 23-07, in alignment with the principles of the
standards. Equally important is enhancing the Accounting Board's role as an internal body including
specialists and experts, to define the IPSAS implementation roadmap, monitor the process, and address
challenges facing it. Furthermore, the findings indicate that the transition to accrual accounting, despite its
advantages, is complex and requires the development of accounting knowledge to move away from
traditional cash-based practices, and underscores the need to develop employee capabilities. These
implications shed light on the importance of supporting educational curricula by teaching IPSAS. Algeria
has recently taken this step partially at some university levels, but a broader application is necessary. Finally,
these practical insights underscore the value of a phased approach to change management, which provides
time to adapt to new systems and face challenges. To explore potential implementation barriers, a pilot
program applying IPSAS within a specific sector would be beneficial. The significance of these findings
extends beyond the local context of Algeria, as they provide valuable strategic insights for countries with
Widad Benzine / Finance, Accounting and Business Analysis, Volume 6, Issue 2, 2024
130
similar circumstances.
This research presents limitations that open avenues for future discussions. Future research could
expand its scope by including other additional institutional, organizational, and individual factors.
Furthermore, it would be beneficial for subsequent research to be conducted across different stages, such as
pre-implementation and post-implementation periods. Moreover, the study' focus on a few provinces
underscores the need for future research to use a larger, more representative sample.
REFERENCES
Aboukhadeer, E. A. S., S. M. F. Azam, and A. R. S. Albattat. 2023. The Realtionship Between International
Public Sector Accounting Standards (IPSAS) and the Quality of Accounting Information in Libyan
Government Sector. International Journal of Professional Business Review, 8(1): 01‑29.
https://doi.org/10.26668/businessreview/2023.v8i1.1264.
Abu Haija, A. A., A. M. AlQudah, L.A. Aryan, and M.J.Azzam. 2021. Key success factors in implementing
international public sector accounting standards. Accounting, 7(1): 239‑48.
ACCA. 2017. IPSAS implementation: current status and challenges .
https://www.accaglobal.com/content/dam/ACCA_Global/Technical/pubsect/pi-IPSAS-
implementation-current-status-and-challenges.pdf.
Acha, F., and L. Ghouini. 2020. La réforme comptable de l’état en Algérie et la nécessite de la mise en place
du système d’information intégré. Revue des Réformes Economiques et Intégration En Economie Mondiale
14(1): 370‑88.
Ademola, A. O., E. Ben-Caleb, J. U. Madugba, A.E. Adegboyegun, and D.F. Eluyela. 2020. International
public sector accounting standards (IPSAS) adoption and implementation in Nigerian public sector.
International Journal of Financial Research, 11(1): 434‑46. https://doi.org/10.5430/IJFR.V11N1P434.
Agyemang, J. K. 2017. Factors Affecting the Implementation of Accrual-Based International Public Sector
Accounting Standards (AIPSAS) in Ghana. Texila International Journal of Management 3 (2): 64‑75.
https://doi.org/10.21522/tijmg.2015.03.02.art007.
Ahmad, A. S., and H. Nasseredine. 2019. Major Challenges and Barriers to IPSASs Implementation in
Lebanon. Proceedings of the International Conference on Business Excellence, 13(1): 326‑34.
https://doi.org/10.2478/picbe-2019-0029.
Al-Kharabsheh, F. I. 2021. The effect of adopting international public sector accounting standards (IPSAS)
on financial performance in the Jordanian public sector. Academy of Accounting and Financial Studies
Journal, 25(2): 01‑12.
Al-Marsomi, M. S. K., and F. M. S. Al-Zwainy. 2023. Structural equation modeling of critical success
factors in the programs of development regional. Journal of Project Management, 8(2): 119‑32.
https://doi.org/10.5267/j.jpm.2022.11.002.
Al-otoom, N. A. T., and H. M. Alrabba. 2022. Impact of Lack of Self-efficiency and Assets Evaluation on
Resistance of IPSAS Implementation. Information Sciences Letters Volume, 11(5): 1771‑79.
AL-Quraishi, A. R. M., and E. Boumediene. 2023. The Impact of the Future Application of International
Accounting Standards in the Public Sector in Developing the Performance of Government Institutions
Applying the Government Accounting System and Its Contribution To Activating the Role By the
Federal B. American Journal of Business Management, Economics and Banking, 17: 28‑45.
Alshujairi, M. H. A. 2024. Government Accounting System Reform and the Adoption of IPSAS in Iraq.
Research Journal of Finance and Accounting, 5(24): 01‑20.
Amiri, A., and S. E. Hamza. 2020. The transition to IPSAS standards: the extent of adoption and the
influence of institutional, contingency and economic network factors. Journal of Accounting and
Management Information Systems, 19(2): 215‑51. https://doi.org/10.24818/jamis.2020.02002.
Amor, D. B., and S. D. Ayadi. 2019. The profile of IPSAS-adopters. Journal of Accounting and Management
Information Systems, 18(2): 262‑82. https://doi.org/10.24818/jamis.2019.02005.
Ashoka, M. L, and P. Aswathy. 2020. A Conceptual Study on Public Sector Accounting System: Benefits
and Challenges. VISION: Journal of Indian Taxation, 7(1): 72‑82.
https://doi.org/10.17492/vision.v7i1.195937.
Auriacombe, C. J. 2010. Survey research: Critical considerations for questionnaire construction. Journal of
Public Administration, 45(3): 473‑88.
Babatunde, S. A. 2017. Implementing International Public Sector Accounting Standards in Nigeria: Issues
and Challenges. International Journal of Business, Economics and Law, 12(1): 52‑61.
Benkouider, H. 2023. L’application du budget-programme en Algérie Implementation of the programme
budget in Algeria. Revue recherche économique contemporaine, 6(1): 439‑52.
Bey, L. 2022. L’application des IPSAS en Algérie un grand chantier non encore amorcé. La revue de l’expert-
Widad Benzine / Finance, Accounting and Business Analysis, Volume 6, Issue 2, 2024
131
comptable, n
o
3: 70-. https://www.cn-onec.dz/images/revue-3-onec.pdf.
Bolívar, M. P. R., A. N. Galera, and L. A. Muñoz. 2015. Governance, transparency and accountability: An
international comparison. Journal of Policy Modeling, 37(1): 136‑74.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpolmod.2015.01.010.
Bouabbana, F. 2020. Project of modernizing the public accounting system in accordance with the
international accounting standards for the public sector (IPSAS) In Algeria, between reality and
challenges. Journal of Economic Sciences Institute, 23(02): 1451‑69.
Boudjellal, M. 2024. The reality of modernizing the public accounting system in Algeria in light of the
adoption of International Public Sector Accounting Standards (IPSAS). Journal of legal and economic
research, 7(2): 781‑806.
Boumediene, M.R., and A. Benramdane. 2024. The contribution of the international public sector
accounting standards IPSAS in developing the public accounting system in Algeria: A field study of a
sample of academics and professionals. Review MECAS, 2024.
Brusca, I., M. Gómezvillegas, and V. Montesinos. 2016. Public Financial Management Reforms: The Role
of Ipsas in Latin-America. Public Administration and Development, 36(1): 51‑64.
https://doi.org/10.1002/pad.1747.
Brusca, I., V. Montesinos, and D. S. L. Chow. 2013. Legitimating International Public Sector Accounting
Standards (IPSAS): the case of Spain. Public Money & Management, 33(6): 437‑44.
https://doi.org/10.1080/09540962.2013.836006.
Byrne, B. M. 2016. Structural Equation Modeling With AMOS: Basic Concepts, Applications, and Programming.
3ed éd. Routledge, Taylor & Francis Group. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781410600219.
Chan, J. L. 2006. IPSAS and Government Accounting Reform in Developing Countries . In Accounting
reform in the public sector: mimicry, fad or necessity, 31‑42.
Cheurfa, N. 2022. La réforme de la comptabilité publique Algérienne: Épiphénomène technique ou
métamorphose paradigmatique?. Les Cahiers du Cread, 38(3): 321‑56.
https://doi.org/https://dx.doi.org/10.4314/cread.v38i3.12.
Chin, W. W. 1998. The partial least squares approach to Structural Equation Modeling. Modern Methods for
Business Research, 295(2): 295‑336.
Christiaens, J., B. Reyniers, and C. Rollé. 2010. Impact of IPSAS on reforming governmental financial
information systems: a comparative study. International Review of Administrative Sciences, 76(3): 537‑54.
https://doi.org/10.1177/0020852310372449.
Christiaens, J., C. Vanhee, F. Manes-Rossi, N. Aversano, and P. Van Cauwenberge. 2015. The Effect of
IPSAS on Reforming Governmental Financial Reporting: an International Comparison. International
Review of Administrative Sciences, 81(1): 158‑77. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11115-022-00625-w.
Collier, J. E. 2020. Applied Structural Equation Modeling Using AMOS: Basic to advanced techniques. Routledge.
https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003018414.
Correa Silva, M. A., A. C. da Silva Junior, M. A. Marques Ferreira, and A. C. Brunozi Júnior. 2022.
Conditioning Factors for the Adoption of International Public Sector Accounting Standards - IPSAS.
Journal of Accounting, Management and Governance, 25(1): 103‑22.
Daddi-ddoun, N., and M. Oudai. 2013. Réforme budgétaire en Algérie: Vers une gouvernance axée sur la
performance. Revue:Reformes Economiques et Intégration en Economie Mondiale, n
o
14: 201‑24.
Diniz, J. A., S. F. S. da Silva, L. Da Costa Santos, and V. G. Martins. 2015. Advantages of the
Implementation of IPSAS in Brazilian Public Accounting: Analysis of the perception of the members
of GTCON. Revista de Educação e Pesquisa em Contabilidade (REPeC), 9(3): 265‑84.
https://doi.org/10.17524/repec.v9i3.1226.
Fahas, M., F. Ayachi, and N. Belouti. 2022. La normalisation de la comptabilité de l’État en Algérie “un
système inspiré des normes comptables internationales du secteur public -IPSAS-”. Revue Algérienne
d’Economie et gestion, 16(1): 379‑94.
Garson, G. D. 2016. Partial Least Squares (PLS-SEM). Statistical Associates Publishing.
https://doi.org/10.1201/b16017-6.
Gkouma, O. G., and J. Filos. 2022. Assessing the Impact of IPSAS on Financial Reporting and Public
Management in Greece. SPOUDAI - Journal of Economics and Business, 72(1/2): 56‑79.
Hair, J. F. Jr., M. C. Howard, and C. Nitzl. 2020. Assessing measurement model quality in PLS-SEM using
confirmatory composite analysis. Journal of Business Research 109 (December 2019): 101‑10.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbusres.2019.11.069.
Hair, J. F. Jr., G. T. M. Hult, C. M. Ringle, and M. Sarstedt. 2017. A primer on partial least squares structural
equation modeling (PLS-SEM). 2 éd. SAGE Publications.
Hair, J. F. Jr., G. T. M. Hult, C. M. Ringle, M. Sarstedt, N. P. Danks, and S. Ray. 2021. Partial Least Squares
Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM) Using R. Structural Equation Modeling: A Multidisciplinary Journal.
Widad Benzine / Finance, Accounting and Business Analysis, Volume 6, Issue 2, 2024
132
Springer. https://doi.org/10.1080/10705511.2022.2108813.
Haji Din, B., and E. O. El Haron. 2023. Factors Influencing Adoption of Accrual Basis International Public
Sector Accounting Standards . International Journal of Accounting and Management Sciences, 2(1): 67‑88.
https://doi.org/10.56830/IJNZ1133.
Henseler, J., C. M. Ringle, and M. Sarstedt. 2015. A new criterion for assessing discriminant validity in
variance-based structural equation modeling . Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 43(1): 115‑35.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11747-014-0403-8.
IPSASB. 2014. IPSASB Strategy Consultation . IFAC.
https://www.aasb.gov.au/admin/file/content102/c3/M138_7.4_IPSASB_Strategy_Consultation_2
015_2019_0.pdf.
IPSASB. 2017. Financial Reporting Under The Cash Basis of Accounting . IFAC.
https://www.ifac.org/_flysystem/azure-private/publications/files/Cash-Basis-IPSAS-2017.pdf.
IPSASB. 2022. Handbook of International Public Sector Accounting Pronouncements. Vol. 1. IFAC.
https://www.ipsasb.org/publications/2022-handbook-international-public-sector-accounting-
pronouncements.
IPSASB. 2023. The conceptual framework for general purpose financial reporting by public sector entities
contents. IFAC. https://ifacweb.blob.core.windows.net/publicfiles/2023-12/IPSASB-Public-Sector-
Conceptual-Framework_2023 - Updated 12-19-23_Secure.pdf.
Janadari, M., S. Ramalu, and C. C. Wei. 2016. Evaluation of Measurment and Structural Model of The
Reflective Model Constructs in PLS-SEM . In Proceedings of the 6th International Symposium—2016 South
Eastern University of Sri Lanka (SEUSL), 187‑94.
Jones, R., and M. Pendlebury. 2010. Public sector accounting. 6
e
éd. Pearson Education Limited.
Khechaimia, K. 2022. Modernisation de la gestion des finances publiques en Algérie Modernization of
public finance management in Algeria . Revue Algérienne de Finances Publiques, 12(01): 30‑48.
Kicová, M. 2017. Financial reporting for public sector entities by conceptual framework. In New Trends in
Process Control and Production Management, 247‑52. POLAND: CRC Press.
https://doi.org/10.1201/9781315163963.
Kissi, F. 2012. Projet de modernisation du système budgétaire en Algérie . AL-IJTIHED Revue des études
juridiques & économiques - C.U.TAM 2: 569‑88.
Krah, R., and G. Mertens. 2023. Financial transparency, trust and willingness to pay in local governments
of sub-Saharan Africa . Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management, 35(6): 100‑120.
https://doi.org/10.1108/JPBAFM-06-2022-0110.
Loi n° 23-07. 2023. « relative aux règles de comptabilité publique et de gestion financière ». In Journal Officiel
de la République Algérienne, n° 42. https://www.joradp.dz/FTP/JO-
francais/2023/F2023042.pdf?znjo=42.
Maruf, M. 2024. Moderating effect of institutional factors on organization factors and financial reporting
quality: Case of IPSAS adoption in local governments of Nigeria. International Journal of Intellectual
Discourse (IJID), 7(1): 245‑72.
Mazhambe, Z. 2021. Implementation challenges of International Public Sector Accounting Standards
(IPSAS ) in Africa. International Journal of Accounting Research, 9(4): 1‑3.
Meadows, K. A. 2003. So you want to do . British Journal of Community Nursing, 8(12): 562‑70.
Miraj, J., and Z. Wang. 2019. Factors Influencing the Implementation of International Public Sector
Accounting Standards in Pakistan. International Journal of Business and Management, 14(9): 15‑22.
Narsaiah, N. 2019. Adoption of international public sector accounting standards (IPSAS) in India:
Feasibility, benefits and challenges. Indian Journal of Accounting (IJA), 51(2): 1‑12.
Ogbuagu, N. M., and J. K. J Onuora. 2019. Effect of IPSAS Adoption on Accountability and Transparency
in the Nigerian Public Sector Organizations. Journal of Accounting and Financial Management E-ISSN,
5(3): 65‑80.
Polzer, T., P. Adhikari, C. P. Nguyen, and L. Gårseth-Nesbakk. 2021. Adoption of the International Public
Sector Accounting Standards in emerging economies and low-income countries: a structured literature
review. Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management, 35(3): 309‑32.
https://doi.org/10.1108/JPBAFM-01-2021-0016.
Purwanto, A., and Y. Sudargini. 2021. Partial Least Squares Structural Squation Modeling (PLS-SEM)
Analysis for Social and Management Research: A Literature Review. Journal of Industrial Engineering
& Management Research, 2(4): 114‑23.
PWC. 2012. Implementing International Accounting Standards in the Public Sector (IPSAS) as part of wider
finance reform.
PWC. 2014. Collection of information related to the potential impact, including costs, of implementing
accrual accounting in the public sector and technical analysis of the suitability of individual IPSAS
Widad Benzine / Finance, Accounting and Business Analysis, Volume 6, Issue 2, 2024
133
standards. https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/documents/1015035/4261806/EPSAS-study-final-PwC-
report.pdf.
Redmayne, N. B., F. Laswad, and D. Ehalaiye. 2019. Evidence on the costs of changes in financial reporting
frameworks in the public sector. Public Money & Management, 41(05): 01‑08.
https://doi.org/10.1080/09540962.2019.1679482.
Roje, G., D. Vašiček, and V. Vašiček. 2010. Accounting regulation and IPSAS implementation: Efforts of
transition countries toward IPSAS compliance. Journal of Modern Accounting and Auditing, 6(12): 1‑16.
Roopa, S, and M. S. Rani. 2012. Questionnaire Designing for a Survey. The Journal of Indian Orthodontic
Society, 46(4): 273‑77. https://doi.org/10.5005/jp-journals-10021-1104.
Saleh, Z., C. R. Isa, and H. Abu Hasan. 2021. Issues and Challenges in Implementing International Public
Sector Accounting Standards (IPSAS). IPN Journal of Research and Practice in Public Sector Accounting
and Management, 11(1): 1‑14.
Salia, H., and W. A. Atuilik. 2018. The implementation of international public sector accounting standards
in Liberia: Analysis of the benefits and challenges. European Journal of Business, Economics and
Accountancy, 6(6): 17‑31.
Sarstedt, M., J. F. Hair, C. Nitzl, C. M. Ringle, and M. C. Howard. 2020. Beyond a tandem analysis of
SEM and PROCESS: Use of PLS-SEM for mediation analyses!. International Journal of Market Research,
62(3): 288‑99. https://doi.org/10.1177/1470785320915686.
Schmidthuber, L., D. Hilgers, and S. Hofmann. 2020. International Public Sector Accounting Standards
(IPSASs): A systematic literature review and future research agenda. Financial Accountability &
Management, 38(1): 119‑42. https://doi.org/10.1111/faam.12265.
Shehadeh, E. 2022. A Movement Towards the Accrual Based IPSAS Implementation in Developing
Countries: Evidence from Jordan. The Journal of Asian Finance, Economics and Business 9 (3): 389‑97.
https://doi.org/10.13106.
Souza, A. C. d., N. M. C. Alexandre, and E. d. B. Guirardello. 2017. Psychometric properties in instruments
evaluation of reliability and validity. Epidemiologia e servicos de saude 26 (3): 649‑59.
https://doi.org/10.5123/S1679-49742017000300022.
Takarli, M., and L. Ghrissi. 2024. State Reforms for Public Accounting in Order to Implement IPSAS
Takarli. Finance & Markets Journal, 11(1): 23‑37.
Tanjeh, M. S. 2016. Factors Influencing the Acceptance of International Public Sector Accounting
Standards in Cameroon. Accounting and Finance Research, 5(2): 71‑83.
Tanujaya, B., R. C. I. Prahmana, and J. Mumu. 2022. Likert Scale in Social Sciences Research: Problems
and Difficulties. FWU Journal of Social Sciences, 16(4): 89‑101.
http://doi.org/10.51709/19951272/Winter2022/7.
Tawiah, V. 2023. The effect of IPSAS adoption on governance quality: Evidence from developing and
developed countries. Public Organization Review, 23(1): 305‑24. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11115-022-
00625-w.
Ursachi, G, I. A. Horodnic, and A. Zait. 2015. How Reliable are Measurement Scales? External Factors
with Indirect Influence on Reliability Estimators. Procedia Economics and Finance, 20(15): 679‑86.
https://doi.org/10.1016/s2212-5671(15)00123-9.
Wang, Z., and J. Miraj. 2018. Adoption of International Public Sector Accounting Standards in Public
Sector of Developing Economies -Analysis of Five South Asian Countries. Research in World Economy,
9(2): 44‑51.
Whitefield, A. A., and P. Savvas. 2016. The Adoption and Implementation of the International Public Sector
Accounting Standards: The challenges faced by the United Nation in producing UN-IPSAS compliant
financial reports in Kenya. International Journal of Finance and Accounting, 1(1): 75‑91.
https://doi.org/10.47604/ijfa.42.
Williams, A. Atuilik, and S. Hussein. 2019. Impact of IPSAS adoption on transparency and accountability
in managing public funds in developing countries: Evidence from Liberia. Journal of Accounting and
Taxation, 11(6): 99‑110. https://doi.org/10.5897/JAT2019.0345.
Wong, K. K.K.. 2019. Mastering Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM) with SmartPLS
in 38 Hours. iUniverse.
Zait, A., and P. E. Bertea. 2011. Methods for testing discriminant validity. Management & Marketing, IX(2):
217‑24.
Zibaghafa, S., and M. Okpolosa. 2024. International Public Sector Accounting Standards Adoption and
Challenges of Implementation in Nigeria. European Journal of Accounting, Auditing and Finance Research,
12(1): 108‑25. https://doi.org/10.37745/ejaafr.2013/vol12n1108125.
Widad Benzine / Finance, Accounting and Business Analysis, Volume 6, Issue 2, 2024
134
Appendix 1. Questionnaire
Research variables and measurement items
References
Implementation
of IPSAS
IMP1
- Implementation of IPSAS is one of the priorities of the
Algerian government.
Whitefield
and Savvas
(2016)
Abu Haija et
al. (2021)
IMP2
- There is a clear political direction for implementing
IPSAS.
IMP3
- The state is making efforts to provide the necessary
support to implement IPSAS.
IMP4
- The government is undertaking important legal reforms to
move towards implementing IPSAS.
IMP5
- The government is adopting a clear roadmap to move
towards full accreditation of IPSAS.
IMP6
- Our administration applies the laws established by the
country in order to implement IPSAS.
Transparency
and
accountability
TRN1
- IPSAS implementation improves the quality of financial
information and supports transparency in government
financial practices.
Alshujairi
(2024)
Al-Kharabsheh
(2021)
Christiaens et
al. (2010)
TRN2
- IPSAS provides a suitable measurement basis for financial
reporting which improves government financial
transparency.
TRN3
- IPSAS raises the level of disclosure and comparability of
information, which increases the transparency of
government financial reports.
TRN4
- IPSAS improves accountability for public sector
performance.
TRN5
- IPSAS improves external oversight and accountability.
TRN6
-IPSAS promotes information transparency and
government accountability to citizens and the general
public.
Accrual basis
ACC1
- Implementing IPSAS contributes to the strong adoption of
the accrual basis in public sector accounting.
Shehadeh
(2022)
Al-Kharabsheh
(2021)
Alshujairi
(2024)
ACC2
- Accrual accounting is more effective than cash accounting
in giving reliable information about the financial position
and performance of the government.
ACC3
- Accrual basis enhances the management of expenses and
receivables.
ACC4
- The accrual basis is considered more useful for managing
assets and liabilities.
ACC5
- The accrual basis provides financial information to
monitor performance and public funds against corruption.
ACC6
- Implementing the accrual basis improves the quality of
financial reports.
International
harmonization
HRM1
-IPSAS implementation achieves international accounting
harmonization for government agencies.
Alshujairi
(2024)
Al-Kharabsheh
(2021)
Salia and
Atuilik (2018)
Ademola et
al. (2020)
HRM2
-IPSAS implementation facilitates the consolidation of
financial statements better than the current accounting
system.
HRM3
- IPSAS implementation ensures that financial reporting is
consistent and globally comparable.
HRM4
- IPSAS implementation helps align with the requirements
of international organizations and development aid
providers.
HRM5
- IPSAS implementation enhances the inflow of foreign
direct investment.
HRM6
- IPSAS implementation facilitates the flow of foreign aid.
Cost
COS1
- IPSAS implementation is associated with high costs.
Ahmad and
Nasseredine
(2019)
COS2
- Seminars and training courses for IPSAS implementation
are expensive.
Widad Benzine / Finance, Accounting and Business Analysis, Volume 6, Issue 2, 2024
135
COS3
- The hardware and software required for IPSAS
implementation involve significant expenses.
Whitefield
and Savvas
(2016)
Agyemang
(2017)
COS4
- Replacing of previous accounting packages incurs high
costs.
COS5
- IPSAS maintenance costs are high.
COS6
- Estimating the overall cost of IPSAS implementation is
difficult.
Skills
SKL1
- IPSAS implementation requires a high level of specific
knowledge and skills.
Agyemang
(2017)
Miraj and
Wang (2019)
Abu Haija et
al. (2021)
SKL2
- There is little general knowledge of IPSAS among
employees.
SKL3
- There is a low level of awareness of the importance of
IPSAS.
SKL4
- Training on IPSAS is necessary to enable employees to
understand it.
SKL5
- The current skills of public sector employees are
insufficient to implement IPSAS.
SKL6
- Training courses available to employees regarding IPSAS
implementation are insufficient.
Structural and
organizational
transformation
STR1
- IPSAS implementation requires changing legislation and
regulations.
Ahmad and
Nasseredine
(2019)
Abu Haija et
al. (2021)
STR2
- Current local legislation is not sufficient for implementing
IPSAS.
STR3
-IPSAS implementation requires modifying accounting
records and practices and modernizing the public
accounting system.
STR4
- IPSAS implementation requires preparing the
infrastructure and having integrated ICT systems.
STR5
-Current hardware and software are insufficient to
implement IPSAS.
STR6
-Government entities lack sufficient internal and external
networks to facilitate the implementation of IPSAS.